Hagaon Rav Yitzchok Zilberstein, the esteemed rov of the Ramat Elchonon neighborhood in Bnei Brak and a member of the Moetzes Gedolei Hatorah of Degel Hatorah, recently addressed a deeply emotional dilemma. During ongoing efforts to secure the release of hostages amidst Israel’s war, Rav Zilberstein met with affected families to provide spiritual support and halachic guidance.
In a poignant case, a mother of a hostage sought the rov’s advice regarding Shabbos observance. Her daughter was slated to be freed on Shabbos, and the mother faced the thorny question of whether she could drive to reunite with her, potentially violating Shabbos.
The Mother’s Emotional Dilemma
The mother approached Rav Zilberstein with a heavy heart, expressing her longing to see her daughter after her release. “She asked me, ‘How will I face this situation? How can I refrain from driving to her on Shabbos?’” Rav Zilberstein recounted.
The mother’s concern reflected the profound emotional and spiritual conflict she faced: the desire to reunite with her child clashed with the sanctity of Shabbos.
Rav zilberstein’s Thoughtful Response
Rav Zilberstein advised the mother not to drive on Shabbos, explaining that it would constitute chillul Shabbos (desecration of Shabbos). Instead, he suggested that she send a picture and a heartfelt letter to her daughter, conveying her love and anticipation for a reunion after Shabbos.
However, the mother pressed further, asking, “What if I can’t control myself? What should I do if I feel I cannot wait to see her?”
Rav Zilberstein responded with profound words of encouragement: “If Hashem has shown His kindness and performed a miraculous act by keeping your daughter alive, we must express our gratitude to Him.” He emphasized the spiritual merit and blessing of exercising restraint to honor Shabbos.
While Rav Zilberstein did not explicitly forbid the mother from traveling, he highlighted the immense bracha (blessing) that would come from holding off until after Shabbos.
Halachic Perspective and Emotional Strength
Rav Zilberstein’s guidance underscores a central theme in halacha: balancing emotional desires with the sanctity of Torah law. His advice reflects both the compassion required for such sensitive situations and the importance of maintaining a commitment to Shabbo’s observance.
This approach demonstrates that while halacha can sometimes present challenges, it also provides avenues for emotional and spiritual growth. It urgesg individuals to rise above their natural impulses in honor of Hashem’s commandments.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Rav Zilberstein advise against traveling on Shabbos in this situation?
Driving on Shabbos is considered chillul Shabbos, which is prohibited according to halacha. Rav Zilberstein emphasized the importance of honoring Shabbos, even in emotionally charged situations, and suggested alternative ways to connect with the released daughter, such as sending a letter and picture.
Did Rav Zilberstein forbid the mother from driving on Shabbos?
No, Rav Zilberstein did not outright forbid the mother from traveling. Instead, he highlighted the spiritual significance and blessing of refraining from chillul Shabbos. His guidance aimed to encourage restraint while recognizing the emotional difficulty involved.
What alternative did Rav Zilberstein propose for the mother to connect with her daughter?
He suggested that the mother send her daughter a picture and a heartfelt letter, reassuring her that they would reunite after Shabbos.
What is the significance of observing Shabbos in this context?
Shabbos observance is a fundamental aspect of Jewish life, representing a covenant with Hashem. By refraining from desecrating Shabbos, the mother would demonstrate gratitude and faith in Hashem, recognizing the miracle of her daughter’s survival.
Conclusion
Rav Yitzchok Zilberstein’s compassionate and wise guidance in this emotional situation reflects the delicate balance between halachic observance and human emotions. While acknowledging the mother’s profound desire to reunite with her daughter, he encouraged her to honor Shabbos as a testimony of faith and gratitude to Hashem.
This story serves as a powerful reminder of the enduring strength of Jewish values, even in moments of deep emotional conflict, and the blessings that come from adhering to Torah principles.