On Sunday, Israel witnessed a moment of profound joy with the release of Doron Steinbrecher, Emily Damari, and Romi Gonen, who were freed from captivity under Hamas. This emotional event highlighted a critical message for Israel’s leadership and defense forces: every captive, especially those still alive, must be returned. The release of these hostages emphasizes the importance of completing this mission, as failing to do so would inflict a deep and lasting scar on Israel’s social fabric and national morale.
The Imperative of Bringing Every Captive Home
Israel’s collective sense of relief over the return of these hostages is tempered by the acknowledgment that the work is far from finished. No military campaign can be considered a success, and the country’s security will remain fragile unless all hostages are returned. Despite the considerable costs involved, such as freeing convicted terrorists, Israel must pursue the goal of returning every captive to their families.
The Next Phase of Negotiations: A Long-Term Ceasefire and Demilitarization of Gaza
Looking ahead, Israel must prepare for the next phase of negotiations, which may pave the way for a long-term ceasefire. However, a ceasefire should not mean a return to the status quo. Israel must ensure that jihadist groups, particularly Hamas, do not regain a foothold in Gaza. It is essential to recognize that Hamas is not a foreign imposition but an integral part of Gaza’s political and cultural identity, supported by a majority of the population.
Strategic Objectives for Israel’s Security
To protect Israeli citizens, particularly those in the western Negev, Israel must articulate clear and actionable terms for ending the violence. The lofty goals of “toppling Hamas” or achieving “total victory” may sound appealing but fail to provide practical solutions. Israel must focus on more achievable objectives.
Demilitarization of Gaza: One of the primary demands should be the demilitarization of Gaza, which would include the dismantling of terrorist infrastructure like tunnels, rocket launchers, mortars, and explosive devices. Suppose international organizations do not step in to enforce these terms. In that case, the IDF may need to take responsibility for this task, even if it requires extended operations lasting over a year.
Removal of Hamas from Governance: Another critical demand is the removal of Hamas from governing Gaza. Interestingly, this may not require significant intervention by Israel, as Hamas has shown a preference for operating as an armed political organization, rather than dealing with the responsibilities of governance. Israel should welcome Hamas stepping back from governing Gaza, but any arrangement that allows the group to retain weapons under silent international approval must be rejected.
Building International Support for Israel’s Strategy
These two objectives—Gaza’s demilitarization and Hamas’s removal from governance—should serve as the foundation for Israel’s strategy in the next phase of discussions. Israel can likely count on support from the U.S. administration, under President-elect Donald Trump, as well as from the broader international community. The call for a demilitarized Gaza is a reasonable and widely supported position.
Ensuring Security and Dignity
The release of Steinbrecher, Damari, and Gonen was a pivotal moment, but Israel must insist that future hostage exchanges occur without public spectacle. Hamas turned the release into a staged event, putting the captives at unnecessary risk. Future transfers should take place in secure, private locations, with the assistance of mediators like the Red Cross to ensure safety.
Acknowledging the Unsung Heroes
While the nation celebrates the return of its captives, it is crucial to recognize the efforts of those who made this possible. The courageous operations of IDF soldiers forced Hamas to agree to a compromise, leading to the release. Behind the scenes, figures like Mossad Director David Barnea and Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar played pivotal roles. Barnea’s success in convincing political leaders to accept the compromise, and Bar’s team’s intelligence work, were essential. Additionally, Maj. Gen. Nitzan Alon’s meticulous coordination ensured not only the safe return of the captives but also prevented further loss of life during combat operations. These unsung heroes deserve the nation’s deepest gratitude.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the significance of the release of Steinbrecher, Damari, and Gonen?
The release of these hostages signifies Israel’s commitment to securing the return of every captive and highlights the need for complete military success. It is a pivotal moment in the broader efforts to protect Israeli citizens and negotiate a lasting peace.
What are Israel’s primary objectives for Gaza moving forward?
Israel’s key objectives include the demilitarization of Gaza and the removal of Hamas from governing the region. These actions are essential for ensuring the long-term safety of Israeli citizens.
How can Israel ensure the safe return of future hostages?
Future hostage exchanges should be conducted in secure, private locations to minimize risks and prevent Hamas from using the releases as propaganda. International mediators, such as the Red Cross, can play a key role in ensuring these exchanges are conducted safely.
What role did the Israeli defense forces and intelligence agencies play in the hostage release?
The IDF’s courageous operations led to the release, while the intelligence efforts of Mossad and Shin Bet were crucial in securing the compromise. Key figures, such as Mossad Director Barnea and Shin Bet chief Bar, played pivotal roles in ensuring the success of the operation.
Conclusion
The return of Doron Steinbrecher, Emily Damari, and Romi Gonen is a bittersweet victory for Israel, highlighting both the hope of returning captives and the challenges that remain. Israel must now shift its focus to the next phase of negotiations, centered on the demilitarization of Gaza and ensuring that Hamas no longer governs the region. Through clear objectives and international support, Israel can pursue a lasting and secure future, while continuing to prioritize the safety and well-being of its citizens.